• GAYRVA.COM
  • ABOUT
  • Mobile Site

GayRVA

  • News & Views
    • Headlines
    • History
    • Op/Ed
  • Arts & Events
    • Calendar
    • Photos
    • Nightlife
    • Submit an Event
  • Lifestyle
    • Food & Drink
    • Dating & Relationships
    • Health & Fitness
    • Style
  • Guide
    • Attractions
    • Bars & Clubs
    • Faith
    • Health & Beauty
    • Hotels
    • Legal Resources
    • Non-Profit, Volunteer & Activism
    • Real Estate
    • Recreation
    • Restaurants
    • Shopping
    • Support & Social Groups
    • Theaters
    • Travel
  • Calendar
  • Advertise
  • Bars & Clubs
  • Business Directory
  • Dating
  • Nightlife
  • Photos
  • Visit Richmond
  • Home
  • >
  • Washington State Supreme Court sides with same-sex couple who was refused service by Christian florist
  • You are not logged in.
  • LOGIN
  • Arts & Events

    Health Brigade Throws Inaugural...

    brigala001
  • News & Views

    Trump To Reverse Obama...

    HHS-4
  • News & Views

    This Man Thinks His...

    itv-this-morning-4_640x345_acf_cropped-1
  • News & Views

    British Man Who Deliberately...

    daryll-rowe-facebook_650x400_61524107676
  • News & Views

    Christian Conservatives Claim Bill...

    oann-4
  • News & Views

    RTD Quietly Apologizes For...

    ggUwXDMz_400x400
  • Arts & Events

    On Their Debut Album,...

    npr-1----farrah-skeiky_wide-05af2f640c5bed5ccb7df1f871116072c1d54b78-s800-c85
  • News & Views

    “Queers Will Burn And...

    michael-hill-4
  • Arts & Events

    “Queer Voices” Brings Needed...

    queervoiceslitcrawl
  • News & Views

    VAVP Brings NERVE: Stories...

    29314750_1888291627850560_5798738618818232320_n

Featured

    • Headlines
    • History
    • Op/Ed
  • Question

    Tacos vs Pizza: You must choose!

    View Results

    Loading ... Loading ...

Washington State Supreme Court sides with same-sex couple who was refused service by Christian florist

New Civil Rights Movement
New Civil Rights Movement
February 17, 2017
    • Tweet

    Read More: religious freedom, Same-Sex Marriage, washington state

    Screen Shot 2017-02-17 at 12.15.54 PM

    Barronelle Stutzman has lost once again, this time in the Washington State Supreme Court. In 2013, the owner of Arlene’s Flowers refused to sell flowers for a long-time customer’s wedding, citing her religious beliefs. In doing so, she violated the state’s nondiscrimination ordinance, and was sued by Robert Ingersoll and Curt Freed. 

    As Zack Ford at ThinkProgress reports, Stutzman has lost various cases on various arguments, including the claim that she did not discriminate against Ingersoll and Freed because of their sexual orientation, and that she did not discriminate because flower arranging is artistic expression protected by the First Amendment.

    “Stutzman herself had admitted that providing flowers to a wedding between Muslims would not constitute an endorsement for Islam, nor would flowers for an atheist wedding have endorsed atheism,” Ford writes.

    Stutzman, who is in her early 70′s, has been offered several opportunities to settle the case, but her attorneys, the Alliance Defending Freedom (ADF), pursued appeal after appeal. They mounted a media (and fundraising) campaign and claimed she ”stands to lose her business, her home, and her personal savings,” if she were to lose her case.

    In reality, prosecutors at one point offered to settle the case for $1000 and a promise to not discriminate again, but she refused. Another settlement offer along the way for $2001 was also refused by Stutzman.

    The couple’s attorneys, the ACLU, also offered an easy settlement. $5000 to a local LGBT nonprofit and, again, a promise to stop discriminating. Stutzman refused.

    There have been three or four suits and appeals. Stutzman has now lost each time.

    Along the way, a GoFundMe campaign raised about $174,000 for either Stutzman or her attorneys.

    In related news, it’s also been a bad week for the Alliance Defending Freedom. The Southern Poverty Law Center this week designated the Christian law firm an anti-gay hate group.

    Here’s the court’s conclusion:

    The State of Washington bars discrimination in public accommodations on the basis of sexual orientation. Discrimination based on same-sex marriage constitutes discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation. We therefore hold that the conduct for which Stutzman was cited and fined in this case-refusing her commercially marketed wedding floral services to Ingersoll and Freed because theirs would be a same-sex wedding-constitutes sexual orientation discrimination under the WLAD. We also hold that the WLAD may be enforced against Stutzman because it does not infringe any constitutional protection. As applied in this case, the WLAD does not compel speech or association. And assuming that it substantially burdens Stutzman’s religious free exercise, the WLAD does not violate her right to religious free exercise under either the First Amendment or article I, section 11 because it is a neutral, generally applicable law that serves our state government’s compelling interest in eradicating discrimination in public accommodations. We affirm the trial court’s rulings.

    To comment on this article and other NCRM content, visit our Facebook page.

    Image of Barronelle Stutzman screenshot via YouTube

      • Tweet

      At the intersection of politics, religion, law, social justice, and civil rights, The New Civil Rights Movement is a broadly cited media organization delivering news and opinion dedicated to the wide interests of the progressive and LGBT communities.

      19756340_10154989523199125_2480589133657696635_n

      Related Stories

      Breaking Glass: VL Cox Creates Art to End Hate

      “Social justice with a historical flair.” This is artist V.L. Cox‘s description for the style and inspiration of her art. Cox is well known for her take on social issues such as equality, racism, and religion. She recently had an exhibition titled Break Glass: A Conversation to End Hate at Longwood University, just over an [...]

      March 29, 2018
      • A Pennsylvania Bridal Shop Is Closing Down So They Don’t Have to Serve LGBTQ Couples, March 14, 2018
      • DOJ backs Colorado baker in same-sex wedding cake case, September 12, 2017
      • White House omits name of First Gentleman of Luxembourg in spouses of world leaders’ photo, May 27, 2017
      • Prev VA House moves anti same-sex marriage bill one step closer to passage
      • Next Richmond-area freshmen Congressman Don McEachin joins House LGBT Equality Caucus
      • Topics
      • Back to top
      ACLU Babe's of Carytown Bob Marshall Carytown Discrimination Diversity Richmond DOMA Equality Virginia Fan Free Clinic Featured Fourth Friday GA 2016 gallery Gay Community Center of Richmond GCCR Godfrey's History HRC Human Rights Campaign Lesbian LGBT LGBTQ LGBT Rights Mark Herring Marriage Equality movie reviews Movies music Nations North Carolina Photos Richmond Richmond Triangle Players ROSMY rva theater RVA theatre Same-Sex Marriage Transgender transgender bathroom use Trump tv jerry University of Richmond VA Pride VCU video

      More News

      • HHS-4 Trump To Reverse Obama Rule Banning Health Care Discrimination Against Transgender People
      • itv-this-morning-4_640x345_acf_cropped-1 This Man Thinks His Medication Made Him Gay — Watch A Doctor Explain the Truth to Him On Live TV
      • daryll-rowe-facebook_650x400_61524107676 British Man Who Deliberately Infected Partners With HIV Gets Life In Prison
      • Recent Posts

        • Health Brigade Throws Inaugural Brigala at LaDiff Saturday
        • Trump To Reverse Obama Rule Banning Health Care Discrimination Against Transgender People
        • This Man Thinks His Medication Made Him Gay — Watch A Doctor Explain the Truth to Him On Live TV
        • British Man Who Deliberately Infected Partners With HIV Gets Life In Prison
        • Christian Conservatives Claim Bill Banning Conversion Therapy Would Also Ban The Bible
      • Friend Activity

      our partners

      Gungho Guide

      QUICK LINKS

      About

      • About GayRVA
      • Advertise
      • Contact Us
      • Privacy Policy

      Arts & Events

      • Photos
      • Nightlife
      • Calendar
      • Archive

      Connect

      • YouTube
      • Twitter
      • Facebook
      • E-Newsletter

      Guides

      • Travel
      • Resources
      • Real Estate
      • Business Directory

      Lifestyle

      • Style
      • Health & Fitness
      • Food & Drink
      • Dating & Relationships

      Partner Links

      • RMCVB
      • Gungho Guides
      • GCCR

      Copyright (c) 2018 GayRVA.com | Website Developed By CO+LAB

      GayRVAout. spoken.

      Continue to GayRVA (X)