Liberty University Sues Its Insurance Carrier for Refusing to Defend Federal Racketeering Lawsuit
Image via CoachJeffThomas.com
Most universities and businesses maintain commercial package liability insurance policies that protect against claims that arise out of bodily injury and damage claims from everything for slip and fall types of claims to negligent maintenance of grounds and dorm facilities. Such coverage does not typically cover federal racketeering charges and other claims based on illegal behavior and conduct by university staff. Thus, it is no surprise that Hanover Insurance Co. refused to accept coverage for or to pay the defense litigation costs associated with a federal racketeering lawsuit arising from the Lisa Miller/Janet Jenkins (University Dean Matt Staver is pictured at left) custody drama involving the alleged kidnapping of a 10-year-old girl in the midst of a same-sex-marriage custody battle. Wikipedia lays out the basis for Janet Jenkins’ lawsuit against Liberty University:
Liberty University’s law school is asking a federal judge to force the school’s insurance company to come to its defense as it fights a federal racketeering lawsuit involving the alleged kidnapping of a 10-year-old girl in the midst of a same-sex-marriage custody battle.
LU law has filed a declaratory judgment action in Lynchburg federal court claiming Hanover Insurance Co. and its affiliates were wrong to deny coverage and a defense for the school in the lawsuit filed by Janet Jenkins.
In her Vermont lawsuit, Jenkins contends agents of Liberty’s law school conspired to aid the 2009 disappearance of then-10-year-old Isabella Miller. The girl and her birth mother, Lisa Miller, fled to Nicaragua with the help of a Virginia pastor who was convicted last summer of aiding an international kidnapping.
The insurance company says it does not owe coverage because Jenkins’ lawsuit does not claim bodily injury, property damage or “personal and advertising injury” under its policies. The insurer cites 18 other bases for denial.
Miller fled the country with the girl and they are still missing. An Amish-Mennonite pastor was convicted in August of aiding and abetting the kidnapping,ChristianNews.Net and Reuters reported at the time.
Miller had worked at Liberty Christian Academy, a school on the same campus as the law school. Jenkins’ suit cites a phone call to Staver’s cellphone by the man who drove Miller to Canada, according to the Sentinel account. Staver says he didn’t speak to the driver that day, and has called Jenkins’ suit against the law school frivolous and outrageous, according to the Sentinel. He is not personally named as a defendant.
“I had no involvement in their departure, had no knowledge that they had departed or intended to depart,” Staver told the Sentinel. “She just disappeared, and we couldn’t reach her anymore.”
Michael Hamar is an out gay attorney in a committed relationship; formerly married and father of three wonderful children; sometime activist and political/news junkie; survived coming out in mid-life and hope to share my experiences and reflections with others. Follow him at Michael In Norfolk.
While Mcdonnell might not get the chance to teach this session, he will get the chance to spend some time behind barsSeptember 16, 2014
- Lesbian Couple Files Lawsuit Challenging Colo. Same-sex Marriage Ban, November 1, 2013
- Kidnapping Virginia Pastor Seeks Second Appeal in VT Court, July 26, 2013
- Update: Pastor Found Guilty In Lesbian Kidnapping Case, August 17, 2012
- Prev The First Annual RVA Burger Week Starts Today!
- Next Movie Reviews: The East & The Bling Ring
- Back to top
- Openly gay employee at Chesterfield Amazon shipping facility attacked
- Report: If same-sex marriage passes SCTOUS muster, Virginia’s LGBTQs will still face hurdles
- NC Governor to veto anti-same sex marriage bill, but senate set to overrule
- Hampton Roads Pride named one of the best small LGBTQ pride fests in the nation
- RVA improve group InstaPlay holding open auditions