Bill to Deny Same-sex Couples Tax Equality Enters VA House
A house bill sponsored by Delegate Bob Marshall (R-13), author of VA’s constitutional ban on same-sex marriage, would change the Virginia state code to further define the tax benefits denied to legally married same-sex couples.
HB 444 states “only those persons who are in a union that is a marriage recognized under Virginia law may file a joint Virginia income tax return for married persons or a separate Virginia income tax return as a spouse.”
Late last year, the Virginia Department of Taxation issued what some called “the most hateful” guidance in the country when it came to same-sex couples. The Virginia guidance requires married same-sex couples to file as single, even though the IRS recognize their marriage and requires them to file as married. This requires complicated tax forms for LGBTQ familes.
Del. Marshall’s bill would go a step further and codify this language.
“It is my considered judgment that we should do this in the very likelihood Mr. McAuliffe is going to exercise some powers he doesn’t really have,” said Marshall in a phone interview.
Mashall referenced the many failed attempts by legislators to get sexual orientation and gender identity into the state’s nondiscrimination policy, and said McAuliffe’s signing of Executive Order #1, which extending the list of protected classes for state employees to include sexual orientation and gender identity, was an overreach of power.
HB 444 hopes prevent any of Gov. McAuliffe from allowing married same-sex couples to file joint tax returns, according to Marshall. “He has no authority to do that, and I suspect, in order for him to follow through on the interests of some of his supporters, he’ll try to do that.”
Marshall said McAuliffe’s supportive language of the LGBTQ community throughout his campaign lead him to draft this bill. “I wanted to make it clear for everybody that the statues in the constitution of VA do not allow him to do this,” said Marshall. “If he persists, I’ve got various legislative options, but there’s always the option of going to court.”
Marshall couldn’t say if he really would take the Governor to court over giving equal tax benefits to legally married same-sex couples, but he didn’t deny the possibility either.
Marshall took steps to reaffirm his stance by asking former Attorney General Ken Cuccinelli to write an opinion on the governor’s powers specifically when it comes to tax law.
In his opinion, Cuccinelli said the Governor could not extend the benefits because of the state’s ban on same-sex marriage. “Such a directive would represent an attempt to exercise legislative powers in violation of the constitutionally mandated separation of powers and would also violate the express terms of Article I, § 15-A of the Virginia Constitution.”
The VA ACLU has made clear its opposition to the bill, saying it “would impose discriminatory tax policies on couples whose marriages are not currently recognized in Virginia.” In a statement on the Richmond Sunlight legislative blog. “even though the federal government has determined that all married couples should be treated the same for federal income tax purposes.”
Requests for comment sent to Governor McAuliffe’s office were not returned by press time.
GayRVA will follow HB 444 through the 2014 GA session.
Top image: Delegat Marshall via Facebook
“…Taxpayers should expect that their money will not be used to support organizations that discriminate.”January 14, 2017
- Bob Marshall threatens the NCAA, calls Forbes fake news, gets confronted by Richmond trans man in “bathroom bill” press conference gone wrong, January 12, 2017
- Study: Del. Marshall’s proposed “bathroom bill” would impact 34K transgender adults and thousands of transgender youth, January 11, 2017
- New Virginia “bathroom bill” is dangerous to transgender youth, January 5, 2017
- Prev Hear All of Against Me!’s New Record “Transgender Dysphoria Blues” via NPR
- Next ‘Mormon Boy’ Returns to RTP To Present Full Trilogy
- Back to top
- First same-sex marriage related bill dies in VA Senate committee (expectedly)
- Longtime RVA lesbian activist Beth Marschak’s speech from March on Monument
- Firehouse Theatre and TheatreLAB open casting call for ‘Heathers: the Musical’
- 5th Wall’s ‘Luna Gale’ explores the dilemma of what is “best” for the child
- The Black Vaudeville experience exposed in Quill Theatre’s original musical drama “Top of Bravery”